The Labour Party has published its manifesto today.  Astonishingly, its 136 pages provide not a single concrete action relating to welfare benefits – the issue has been almost entirely airbrushed from the document, leaving disabled claimants with no idea what Labour has in store for them.

The closest thing to an actionable idea relating to benefits is on page 78 of the manifesto, which says:

“Labour is committed to reviewing Universal Credit so that it makes work pay and tackles poverty. We want to end mass dependence on emergency food parcels, which is a moral scar on our society.”

So, a review will take place at some undefined time, but with no hint of whether the intention is to increase or reduce UC for disabled claimants, increase or reduce sanctions or anything else.

The document does say on page 42 that:

“We will tackle the backlog of Access to Work claims and give disabled people the confidence to start working without the fear of an immediate benefit reassessment if it does not work out. We believe the Work Capability Assessment is not working and needs to be reformed or replaced, alongside a proper plan to support disabled people to work.”

 But this tells readers nothing concrete. When will reform or replacement of the WCA happen and what form will it take? It sounds like Labour has no clear ideas on the subject, just a vague aspiration.

There is, though, the obligatory threat on page 42 to people who are not in work but, in the view of the Labour Party, should be:

“Labour will reform employment support so it drives growth and opportunity. Our system will be underpinned by rights and responsibilities – people who can work, should work – and there will be consequences for those who do not fulfil their obligations.”

On child poverty, the document says on page 79:

“Labour will develop an ambitious strategy to reduce child poverty. We will work with the voluntary sector, faith organisations, trade unions, business, devolved and local government, and communities to bring about change.”

This suggests that there is no intention to increase benefits payments related to children or to remove the two-child benefit cap introduced by the Tories in 2017, which has been such a driver of child poverty.

Aside from that, there is an undertaking to retain the triple lock for the state pension and a stern warning that Labour “will not tolerate fraud or waste anywhere, whether in social security or the excessive use of consultants”.

And that’s all we could find, please do tell us in the comments section if you discover anything else.

This is a cruel manifesto from the point of view of disabled claimants. 

The Conservatives put in motion some ferociously anti-disabled claimant plans, including moving forward the forced migration to universal credit, making the WCA harder to pass, consulting on replacing PIP with vouchers and spying on bank accounts.

But it will be Labour, not the Conservatives, who are virtually certain to be in charge of claimants’ fate after the election. 

Labour’s decision to give no hint of which Tory plans they will reject and which they will adopt will leave many claimants in a state of real distress for weeks to come.

You can download the Labour Party manifesto from this link.

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
People in conversation:
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Andrew breeze · 6 hours ago
    What are vouchers going to replace we still need to pay bill buy clothes etc government treating us like sheep as usual
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Jonathan Hodge · 2 days ago
    I won't vote for anyone, the country is in such a mess that nobody can fix it. I hate being British, i hate the country and looking to leave the place at the earliest opportunity.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Claire · 2 days ago
    I live in Scotland and to my great relief have had my PIP changed over to the Scottish version ADP but my heart goes out to all those on PIP who are rightly terrified by the changes the Tories plan to make and unsure if and how different things will be under the Labour Party. It is an absolute disgrace that genuine claimants are treated as though we are all liars and crooks trying to steal from the government when it's the government who steals from the people of this country.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    helen shakles · 5 days ago
    I feel like I'm being deleted from the timeline phased out of existence, surplus to requirements ,and my mental health,the illness that caused me to have to retire from work because of it's severity is being made out to be something I just conjured up because I'm  a poor excuse for a human being and I can't cope with life.ive had endless trauma in my life and now not only will I have no independence but no quality of life,I'll likely lose my home my expenses can't really be quantified any other way other than the cost of what it is to live these days.an insult to injury I'm on disbelief I may aswell just end it
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Helen · 1 days ago
      @Phil Reform will be worse, I promise you. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Phil · 3 days ago
      @helen shakles Hi Helen, I just read your plight and feel the same myself, I'me try to decide who to vote for as this Tory government is driving us down, I looked at labour and there manifesto but seems to have no consise promises of plans to help the disabled, of people with mental health such as myself, how we stand with our befits, don't ever feel like that about yourself, theres thousands of us that are feeling unsure and very vulnerable, the conservatives are hell bent on picking on them with little and I genuinely thought the Labour party as a majority might have compassion but theres no clear awnser from them, I might vote reform yet but it seems like a heavy handed party, I feel lost about who to vote for and my only thought is that Labour, even with there faults could offer us a brighter light, nothing can be worse than the conservatives, we just have to live in hope that the next government will help them in need with disabilities and struggles 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Sandie · 3 days ago
      @helen shakles I'm in a similar place, it's really difficult and incredibly stressful to be in the position of not knowing what will happen next. 
      After paying into the system for years it would be good to know that there's help available when you need it. 
      I've been waiting two and a half years for help, for specialist counselling that targets my problems. I've been told it will be Oct this year at the earliest and it could be longer. If there were the resources to help me sooner I might have been back in work by now, not still suffering and unable to function. 
      What a mess the current government has made of the NHS. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Keith · 5 days ago
    Was it not under Blair/brown that  the WCA was brought in🤔
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    CC · 5 days ago
    Sadly I have tried to meet up with Kendall who is my MP, but she holds no surgeries and dodges anyone who wants to talk to her about policies, she even refused attendance of a local hustings event.  I considered sitting on the bench all day opposite her office but that was perhaps too extreme so didnt go that far.
    However Labour have already said they plan to reduce eligibility by WCA reform, so I believe the mentioning of that in the manifesto is very likely related to that, it wouldnt surprise me if they end up being not too dissimilar to the already announced WCA changes by the DWP, PIP not being mentioned is hopefully good news.
    The current WCA qualifies many more people for LCWRA than when it was originally launched by Labour.  They targeted IB when last in power, and to me its not a surprise they targeting it again, still with the Tories going completely bonkers, its probably the lesser evil.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Kieran · 5 days ago
      @CC You as well? Liz has avoided speaking to me for a couple of months, 3 requests for an appointment gone unanswered and the local surgery she held near the King Richard road and Hinckley road has disappeared
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    SkyB · 6 days ago
    Starmer has broken every promise on which he sailed to leadership a few years ago.  I wouldn't trust him as far as I could throw him. I'm a former Labour Party member, and still angry at how Jeremy Corbyn was ousted for this stuffed shirt who now wants a second lucrative career. Labour will win the election, but what it will mean for sick and disabled people goodness only knows. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Marble · 6 days ago
    They introduced means tested benefits. They will do the same as the tories being disabled is now making you a target very 1938 where by Hitler targeted disabled ppl. Its utterly disgusting this singling out and abuse aimed at ppl who are vunrable. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Bee · 1 days ago
      @Marble Exactly my thoughts . They just love degrading us ,belittle us . Trying to make our life even harder 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Bee · 1 days ago
      @Jan I was born in Germany  . I know for sure they did more . Anyone with a dissabilty ,chronic illness got locked up or worse .  Including people with MS .they just vanished  .and I had exactly the same thoughts .  Like us disabled made out scroutcher , costing too much money . We all just should pop it .   
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Jan · 2 days ago
      @Marble It is not acceptable to use Hitler - in any posting.  The Nazi aim was for a 'pure' Arian race, and they did this by - among other horrors - sterilizing the incapable, vulnerable people.  I feel sure that you are not suggesting that the Labour Party intends to carry this out.  Please do not ramp up comments in this way.  It is disgusting and unnecessary.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Amber · 6 days ago
    Rachel Reeves has made a very clear statement that the Labour's manifesto, unlike that of the Tories, has no need to and absolutely no plans, to cut any benefits at all.
    They will not, she said, carry out the Tory cuts.
    This is reassuring, particularly for those on PIP.
    It is disappointing that Labour did not include some sort of reassurance in their manifesto. 
    But we all know that is just to keep the Tory press off their backs, ahead of the election.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      James · 1 days ago
      @Amber Or is it to use some of the the green paper and wash away anything they don't like. The years spent fighting for disabity rights and the fact thus country used to support there disabled people was a good British right, but now it seems our leaders want to save money and the disabled are the first to be hit. Were will they go next child benefit or the benefit a disabled person children money they get of universal credit? Seems cruel don't it, but I bet if the pip is changed then that might be next. I'm disabled with a 4 year old and it's hard I'm wheelchair bound with an amputated leg which as caused the hip to get arthritis and the arthritis is now spreading all over my body, and it's still hard to go the month to give my child a some what normal life and the thought of losing the pip scares me. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      CC · 5 days ago
      @Amber In the last budget she said (on camera) she will adjust the WCA descriptors to cut eligibility, she has also said she will leave PIP alone.  So I think PIP might have a reprieve but I can see WCA changes coming to cut eligibility.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Sue · 6 days ago
    I've worked as a welfare rights policy officer for a large third sector organisation and as a casework manager for a politician. I can well understand the confusion and distress being experienced by many,  but would comment as follows. As a claimant, carer or support provider, dont assume that your MS/MSP/MP has any understanding or knowledge of the benefit system. You are very likely to know more than them, particularly after July when we are going to have a huge influx of new people representing us in the UK parliament.  They will need to be educated about welfare issues and you are the people to do it. They need to hear from you, in person preferably, about the importance and cost effectiveness of a robust state safety net to support people who cannot work due to mental or physical health issues.  If you can't get to a surgery then ask to meet them, and keep in regular touch with them about your concerns. An MP worth their salt will want to hear from you and will use their constituent's experiences as evidence in select committees etc, you may even be invited to attend a select committee   (I was). Ask them to pass on your concerns to the relevant Minister by writing to them and sharing the response with you. I think that Labour is being cautious because they know that they are going to inherit a mess and dont want to make false promises, but new Labour MPs will want to get a grip on the issues that matter to their constituents, unlike our current Tory MP who is known for his three jobs outside parliament (something Labour has committed to end btw) and lack of interest in or consultation with organisations and individuals representing vulnerable people.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      CC · 5 days ago
      @Sue In my case its different, my MP is the shadow secretary of state for the DWP.
      She has refused all attempts to engage, even larger public events.  Holds no surgeries.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Rose · 6 days ago
    I don't trust Starmer to be any different than the Tories once he gets in power. I certainly don't trust him to care about the well-being and welfare of those of us who are disabled. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Jan · 2 days ago
      @Rose What a vacuous comment.  No substance.  Pure conjecture.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Clare · 6 days ago
    As the Labour mantra seems to be Say as little as possible for as long as possible Who knows what they might end up doing When what we want  to know is What are they going to do ?How is it going to be achieved? What will the true cost be ? and what is it going to mean for me ? They do not want to give too much away as  they see it can only cost them votes With  having such a big lead in the polls 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Marble · 6 days ago
      @Clare They introduced means tested benefits they will try and implement the tories green paper 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Michelle · 6 days ago
    It’s about time all parties show the cut of their cloth where pip is concerned, I’m sick to the back teeth of the tories if I’m honest but don’t believe any of the other parties are prepared to put disabled people on their agendas either, if a country can’t look after its disabled, elderly or children then what use are they? 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Alison Hammond · 6 days ago
    Labour can’t be trusted on benefits anymore than Libcon.  They will attack claimants like they did under the Blair days 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      mark · 6 days ago
      @Alison Hammond thats why big buissnes firms are backing them and not the same lab as before got to be better than the torries 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    James Smith · 6 days ago
    I have experienced the Conservative system of Work Capability Assessment when I was forced into early retirement in 2009 and my efforts to claim DLA.
    Three appeals, and four Assessments failed, next cause of action was an Upper Level Tribunal which I attended with my wife and a representative from Disability Services at Disability North.
    This Tribunal upheld my claim at the first attempt, I was awarded High levels for Care and Motability.
    This coming Election will most certainly mean that I will be voting for Labour. The Conservatives can disappear into the sunset for all eternity as far as I'm concerned.


  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Kathy Clarke · 6 days ago
    We can’t be any worse off than if people vote the Tories back in, and yes I receive PIP. The Tories are selfish, arrogant and this country, including the NHS is a mess. We need a change and I am going to put my trust in the Labour Party. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    John Mac · 6 days ago
    They can all promise what they like in their Manifestos and then renege on their promises as there is no recourse for constituents either against a Party or an individual MP. Even more of a problem in Wales as we have both an MP and a Welsh Assembly Member to deal with if both the MP and AM are in the same party it is a bit easier but when they are in different partys all they do throughout their term in office is to try and belittle each other and respective party. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Don 67 · 6 days ago
    They should scrap universal credit which is totally unfit for purpose, the brain child of the evil I D S who sbould be serving time for the hardships, severe hardships and deaths he caused when head of the DWP.  The Tories proposed changes to PIP should be scrapped. The billions they propose to take out of welfare is a drop in the ocea  compared to the over a hundred billion pounds of government fraud since 2019 alone. They truly are the nasty party make no mistake about that!
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Blanche · 6 days ago
    We all need more clarity from all parties on how they are going to treat or reform welfare benefits for disabled people on PIP or DLA. We worked all our lives. We struggle all the time.  I am now retired and been on DLA Indefinite award for sometime now. I have constant infections and major leg problems with Lymphoedema and Arthritis and exhaustion.  My husband has Bone Marrow Cancer. We are basically carers for each other. Surely we need more assurance that thousands of cases similar to ours will not have their benefits altered or taken away cruelly for vouchers, catalogues etc.  We struggle every day in just doing the basic household chores. As it looks like Labour will make the next government we pray they think of people like us, who try to carry on and really don't ask for much.  
    Clarity from all is absolutely needed for those with genuine health and disability problems.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Anne Marie · 6 days ago
    They are like that in many aspects of the manifesto-vague promises but no real substance! I think they are probably the better of the two evils, the other being the Tories, but that’s not saying much, is it? I think, like most people, that I am just disillusioned with politicians who make pie in the sky promises which they don’t deliver. I can’t believe they think we’re so gullible! 
We use cookies

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential for the operation of the site, while others help us to improve this site and the user experience (tracking cookies). You can decide for yourself whether you want to allow cookies or not. Please note that if you reject them, you may not be able to use all the functionalities of the site.