The DWP has today published the details of the twelve members of the Timms review steering group and many people will be disappointed at the make-up of the panel.  

The chosen group of high-achievers will doubtless have much experience and knowledge to offer and almost all  have lived experience of disability or long-term health conditions. But ordinary claimants struggling to make ends meet and deal with DWP bureaucracy seem to be almost entirely, if not entirely, unrepresented.

The short biographies given below also do not seem to list anyone who has had a career specifically in welfare benefits advocacy, who would be in a strong position to challenge the DWP on the technical and legal aspects of any proposed changes.

As well as announcing the committee members, the DWP have revealed that the Public Service Consultants and the West of England Centre for Inclusive Living will oversee the delivery of co-production.

The steering group have already had their first introductory call and the next few weeks will see:

  • the first formal steering group meetings
  • the beginning of detailed co-production and policy work in February
  • preparation for a wider, fully accessible programme of engagement beyond the steering group, starting in the spring

The members of the steering group are as follows:

Dr Mark Brookes MBE is currently the Advocacy Lead for Dimensions UK. He has more than 30 years’ experience in publicly advocating for people with learning disabilities and autism and campaigning against hate crime. Mark works with the Churchill Foundation, the Equality and Human Rights Commission, the NHS Advisory Board, the Crown Prosecution Service, the Home Office, and UK Police forces.

George Fielding BEM is a disability rights advocate who has worked nationally across many public services, with operational expertise in youth work, social care, and community capacity building. He has previously co-founded two CQC-regulated social care providers whilst initiating and developing three youth-led social movements, working to develop intergenerational best practice in social change. He is non-executive advisor to three community interest companies which specialise in co-production.

Tara Flood is a long-time disability rights activist, having worked at a local, national and international level. She is currently Head of Co-production at the London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham. She champions the Social Model of Disability, working with residents to drive policy change and the redesign and delivery of services at a local level.

Mark Fosbrook is a retired Paralympic athlete who brings his own lived experience, and constantly draws on knowledge from others through a person-centred, values-led mindset. As Disability Inclusion Manager at West Midlands Combined Authority, he is driven by advocating for empowering the voices of others, championing change in Transport, Housing, Employment, Health and Social Care.

Ben Geiger is a Professor at King’s College London, and brings academic expertise as well as experience in policy development (including from within the Department for Work and Pensions) and co-production. He currently leads the Welfare Experiences project (comparing how it feels to claim benefits in five countries), and previously co-led the major rapid response study of benefits during COVID-19.

Katrina Gilman is a passionate advocate for disability equality, drawing on lived experience of multiple disabilities and her role as a carer. After 25 years in policing, she now works to break down barriers and champion fairness, accessibility, and opportunity—driving change that empowers disabled people to thrive.

Jean-André Prager has an extensive policy background in PIP and broader disability issues. He was previously the Prime Minister’s Special Adviser covering the Department for Work and Pensions and is currently a Senior Fellow at Policy Exchange and a Director at Flint Global.

Dr Lucy Reynolds is a social entrepreneur, public speaker and disability rights advocate. Founder of We Are All Disabled CIC and Chair of Disability North, she champions an Affirmative approach to disability, using lived experience and academic research to challenge perceptions and drive inclusive cultural change.

Dr Felix Shi brings lived experience as a disabled academic, alongside comparative insights into disability policy across multiple national contexts. As a former board member of Disability Wales and a current member of the Arfon Access Group, Felix works to connect policymakers with grassroots DPOs in Wales.

Dr Dharshana Sridhar is Head of Public Affairs at the Spinal Injuries Association, representing the voices of people with spinal cord injuries nationally. With lived experience as a long-term carer and extensive UK government and international policy expertise, she works to shape fair social security policy and champion the rights, dignity and independence of disabled people and marginalised communities.

Phil Stevens is Chief Executive of Disability Action Haringey and Chair of the Board of Trustees of Disability Action in Islington. He is a disabled leader with extensive experience in user-led advocacy, policy, and strategic development, working to advance rights, access, and inclusion for D/deaf and inclusive events for disabled young people in the UK, and former Director of Autistic Knowledge Development in Scotland, she brings expertise in creating inclusive spaces disabled people across London. [As published by the DWP, but the last part of this biography appears to relate to Leila Talmadge, below]

Leila Talmadge is an autistic and dyslexic project manager and designer. As the former Chair of the Board of Trustees at Daytrippers charity, which provides inclusive events for disabled young people in the UK, and former Director of Autistic Knowledge Development in Scotland, she brings expertise in creating inclusive spaces.

You can read the full Timms update here.

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
People in conversation:
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 4 hours ago
    So who is going to fight the good fight for us impoverished disabled and mentally ill people? By the looks of it PIP will soon be gone as will the disabled aspect of UC. We will just be added to the growing number of homeless statistics, we are the lowest of the low to all these privileged people.  I have just come out of hospital after being sectioned and now im losing my house and will be on  the street by next week with no help or care. I have Bipolar disorder, psychosis, autism, diabetes type one, hypertension and stomach issues but no help and soon to be on the streets because of being sectioned. No help from my local authority as they say i don't qualify for help as i don't fit the criteria. So please use this as a cautionary tale, this could be you, this most defiantly will be if this government gets it s way with our benefits system.  I am also using this to say good bye to the people who have been kind to me on here. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 1 hours ago
      @Kevin @Kevin it won’t be gone autism psychosis bi polar disorder should be enough to get it ok it might be a bit tougher and theirs the severe conditions route too and lcwra might be extended a little bit longer for exaiating claimants 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 1 hours ago
      @Kevin @Kevin You qualify for band A housing sectioned and no fault homeless you will be number 1 in the queue right away just get yourself on the registar  at your local social housing provider and start bidding Angela is also correct what she said below me too
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 1 hours ago
      @Kevin It maybe worth seeing if your local community mental health team (CMHT) can help. They maybe able to assess your housing need based on health and maybe able to get the local authority housing department to do something. They often have local authority social workers as part of the mental health team. And often assist to obtain sheltered or supported housing or to prevent homelessness.

      You may have been referred to your local mental health team when you were discharged from hospital or be able to get your GP to refer you. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 1 hours ago
      @Kevin Hi Kevin,
      Do consider giving the Samaritans a call. I found them so kind and helpful when I needed support – even though I found it hard to make the call. There are still so many kind people out there who can help you find a way through – even if things might seem impossible at the moment. There’s also Mind off the top of my head. Sending lots of good wishes your way.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 3 hours ago
      @Kevin Haven't the local authority got a duty of care to you because of disabilities.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 4 hours ago
    Wow all us impoverished disabled and mentally ill people from working class backgrounds feel well represented, by these privileged people. This is just another form of class warfare, this time the wealthy who "represent" us form backgrounds they couldn't even imagine as usual sit in judgment. 

    Being poor with a disability and mental health problems or disorders is hell, far worse than these wealthy people could ever understand. We are not represented and realistically no one really gives a damn. You're a drone to pay taxes so the rich don't have to and if by a disability or mental health problems you can't your're viewed as the lowest of the low, by the government, the press and those who are privileged and then they encourage the rest of the population to do the same.  
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 5 hours ago
    'Successful' people. Successful 'disabled' people. The exceptional, most able and consequently privileged examples of all people, assessing the needs and capability of the least able. You can see the ladder being hauled up by strong arms.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 6 hours ago
    Nobody with expertise in mental illness. Shocking and very worrying.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 6 hours ago
    "Disabled people will have their voices at the centre of the first ever comprehensive review of Personal Independence Payment (PIP). The group of appointed members will bring lived experience of disability or long-term health conditions as well as direct experience of working within Disabled People’s Organisations."

    A quick google search of the group.

    Jean-André Prage. Former special advisor on the DWP to Prime Minister Rishi Sunak. Not sure but going by Google does not appear to be disabled. Senior Fellow, Policy Exchange and Director, Flint Global. Policy exchange wants PIP for those aged 16-30 to be conditional on engaging in looking for work, engaging in further education or training, volunteer work.

    Dr Ben Geiger Ph.D. Professor of Social Science and Health at King's College London. Former policy advisor to the DWP under the Tory government. Not sure but going by Google does not appear to be disabled. Co-leads work, welfare reform and mental health programme, and co-leads the welfare experience project.

    Dr Dharshana Sridhar, medical doctor. Independent advisor to the UK government. Lived experience as a long-term carer. Head of Public Affairs, Spinal Injuries Association.

    Katrina Gilman. Lived experience of multiple disabilities. National Officer for Disability Equality, UNISON (Labour affiliated union which is one of the largest donors to the Labour party)

    Dr Felix Shi Ph.D. Has visual impairment. Lecturer in Management, Bangor University. Works to understand the experience of disabled people to provide a voice for those less represented in academia. Former board member of Disability Wales and current member of the Arforn Access Group. Seeks to connect policy makers with grassroots DPOs. Comparative insights into disability policy across multiple national contexts.

    Dr Lucy Reynolds Ph.D. Has cerebral palsy. Chair of Board of Trustees, Disability North, and Founder, We Are All Disabled CIC. Public speaker and social entrepreneur. Works with the Affirmative model of disability which celebrates difference and the unique skills and attributes that disabled people bring to the workplace and wider society.

    Dr Mark Brookes MBE, honorary doctorate. Has a learning disability. Advocacy lead for Dimensions UK, checking people are supported in a personalised way. Public speaker and campaigner on disability hate crime and for people with learning disabilities and autism to be treated equally.

    George Fielding BME . Wheelchair user with cerebral palsy. Disability rights advocate and Non-Executive Advisor, social care entrepreneur. Campaigns for wheelchair users.

    Dr Mark Fosbrook, honorary doctorate. Paralympic wheelchair volleyball, rugby and international wheelchair basketball gold winner. Exemplar for engaging disabled people and those with long term health conditions to be physically active. Disability Inclusion Manager, West Midlands Combined Authority

    Tara Flood. Paralympic Gold medal winning swimmer, Head of Co-production, London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham. Campaigns for inclusion in education, champions the social model of disability.

    Phil Stevens, CEO, Disability Action Haringey, and Chair of the Board of Trustees, Disability Action in Islington. Advance rights, access and inclusion for deaf and disabled people.

    Leila Talmadge. Autistic and dyslexic. Founder and former Director, Autistic Knowledge Development CIC. Improving the lives and opportunities of autistic people.


    So just your average everyday disabled people like you would have expected from the DWP asking the general public to apply. Not. Why did they even bother to ask the general public to apply? When they have appointed former government and DWP advisors, a representative of a big Labour affiliated union, people with Ph.Ds, people with honours MBE, BME, Paralympic athletes, a CEO and a founder and director of an organization. These do not seem like typical Joe Average everyday lived experience people.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 4 hours ago
      @John Thank you as always John for bringing in that really good reality check & summary so it can all be seen in one place. In my honest opinion, it feels like the very worst sham. I particularly dislike the way they have appointed 12 people, as if they are the 12 disciples and it brings with the spirit of Christianity. And as a Christian myself, I cannot begin to tell you how far I feel this is from being Christian. In my honest personal opinion, there could be nothing more heinous than dressing up cutbacks to some of the most vulnerable people in our society in some sort of fake altruism that pretends to be enabling them in someway via those cutbacks,  and which conflates  work with good health. It is one of the most Dickensian pieces of damaging tripe I’ve had to be exposed to. Whomever voted Labour  and did not see this coming fand I don’t think any of the other parties would be better and many of them worse), it is extremely frightening to think that there is not one government that is not trying to flush disabled people down the toilet. What is also increasingly worrying is the divide and conquer approach. The oldest political trick in the book. In my honest opinion, I believe it’s so none of us - in our panic -look to tax the super Rich. Please do look to - because the Patriotic  millionaires and tax justice UK are campaigning hard for that to happen, including backed up by Oxfam who have waded in today. But far more importantly is that the disabled must not start fighting amongst themselves because it’s like ‘The Hunger Games’. No disability is worse than any other disability and yes invisible disabilities do seem to be the ones that disappear from the agenda the most and I think these people will be the ones to be very quickly dispensed with. Invisible disabilities do not engender the same compassion that physical ones do. But there I go falling for that very trick… This is one of the most disgraceful, and I say that with Christian connotations, shams I have ever seen. They may have the power to do it, but I think it will have a pile of costly unintended consequences including the fall of this Labour government. Squeezing blood out of the stone of disabled people will not solve this society‘s problems. Now. Or ever.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 7 hours ago
    Nothing for those with sensory impairments and diabetes ....
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 1 hours ago
      @John Thanks for correcting me.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 6 hours ago
      @Matt Phil Stevens, CEO, Disability Action. Advance rights, access and inclusion for deaf and disabled people.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 6 hours ago
      @Matt Dr Felix Shi Ph.D. Has visual impairment
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 8 hours ago
    Jean-Andre Prager. From Flint Global, which advises international companies and investors on issues such as tax, asset management and mergers.

    “Jean-André advises on UK policy and politics.
    He was the Prime Minister’s Special Adviser in the Downing Street Policy Unit for Rishi Sunak (2022-2024) covering both the Department for Work and Pensions and the Department for Culture, Media and Sport. Previous to this, he served as the Prime Minister's Special Adviser for the Department for Work and Pensions for both Boris Johnson (2019-2022) and Theresa May (2018-2019). He was a core member of the Conservative Party manifesto team in both 2019 and 2024 and was involved in numerous budgets and spending reviews.

    From Wikipedia on Policy Exchange, where Prager is a senior fellow: Policy Exchange is a British conservative think tank based in London. In 2007 it was described in The Daily Telegraph as "the largest, but also the most influential think tank on the right". Policy Exchange is a registered charity; it mostly refuses to disclose the sources of its funding and is ranked as one of the least transparent think tanks in the UK. It was founded in 2002 by the Conservative MPs Francis Maude and Archie Norman, and by Nick Boles, who later also became a Tory MP.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 6 hours ago
      @Dan Thanks for doing this research. Does anyone have the energy to do some research on the other members?
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 7 hours ago
      @Dan There's a glowing example of how the Timms review committee is designed to con everyone into thinking that co-production has been involved in drawing up the new PIP system. Yet here we have a blue Tory, who has participated in decisions which have harmed claimants, as one of its advisors!!
      I think the disabled community should boycott the work of this sham committee. How can you have a committee, whose work will affect the lives of millions of people, not have one person who is actually a claimant? 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 8 hours ago
    I have to say I don’t feel very represented by any of the above.