- Posts: 59
× Members
ESA and DLA claims and appeals
- jan
- Topic Author
14 years 2 weeks ago #34085 by jan
ESA and DLA claims and appeals was created by jan
Hi
Have been busy browsing the forum seeking some enlightenment regarding both the above.
I have just had my DLA renewal turned down partly based on my ATOS medical which was carried out in August 2010 (of which I am in the process of appealing having found that the medical report doesn't even mention my fibromyalgia at any point despite having been discussed and that the meds i was taking to manage my sypmtons have been listed to show me as suffering from depression.
This was my 2nd ESA claim following a failed appeal back in May 2010 when i was advised to reclaim - what they didn't tell me was that no benefit would be paid until the medical.
Was advised after the failed ESA to sign up for JSA in order to have monies to live on and to back date the claim back to my last ESA payment. The JSA was awarded however the back claim was denied despiting completing a form to show looking for work (again as advised by the benefits help line)
My JSA Disabilities Employment Adviser has restricted my working abilities to 2 hours per day and has also expressed concern at my obvious ill health which has been impacted on by a deteriorated diabetes problem and inability to take medications due to allergic reactions to them.
My ESA Tribuanl Hearing is currently waiting to be moved to the Upper Tribunal at the request of CAB.
I understood that both ME/CFS and Fibromyalgia are recognised disabilites but have got so confused by all the contradictions not sure where i stand at the moment.
Have been busy browsing the forum seeking some enlightenment regarding both the above.
I have just had my DLA renewal turned down partly based on my ATOS medical which was carried out in August 2010 (of which I am in the process of appealing having found that the medical report doesn't even mention my fibromyalgia at any point despite having been discussed and that the meds i was taking to manage my sypmtons have been listed to show me as suffering from depression.
This was my 2nd ESA claim following a failed appeal back in May 2010 when i was advised to reclaim - what they didn't tell me was that no benefit would be paid until the medical.
Was advised after the failed ESA to sign up for JSA in order to have monies to live on and to back date the claim back to my last ESA payment. The JSA was awarded however the back claim was denied despiting completing a form to show looking for work (again as advised by the benefits help line)
My JSA Disabilities Employment Adviser has restricted my working abilities to 2 hours per day and has also expressed concern at my obvious ill health which has been impacted on by a deteriorated diabetes problem and inability to take medications due to allergic reactions to them.
My ESA Tribuanl Hearing is currently waiting to be moved to the Upper Tribunal at the request of CAB.
I understood that both ME/CFS and Fibromyalgia are recognised disabilites but have got so confused by all the contradictions not sure where i stand at the moment.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- originaldave
14 years 2 weeks ago #34092 by originaldave
Replied by originaldave on topic Re:ESA and DLA claims and appeals
jan wrote:
they are its just the DWP think no one has it
they get away with this point of view and try it on because of the absence of objective diagnostic tests for both conditions, its a lottery when it comes to drs being able to understand all your problems, good drs are hard to find and the dwp have none working for them
you have to get as many reports and back up you can get and fight them
Hi
I understood that both ME/CFS and Fibromyalgia are recognised disabilites but have got so confused by all the contradictions not sure where i stand at the moment.
they are its just the DWP think no one has it
they get away with this point of view and try it on because of the absence of objective diagnostic tests for both conditions, its a lottery when it comes to drs being able to understand all your problems, good drs are hard to find and the dwp have none working for them
you have to get as many reports and back up you can get and fight them
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Rainbowlight
- Offline
Less More
14 years 2 weeks ago #34095 by Rainbowlight
Replied by Rainbowlight on topic Re:ESA and DLA claims and appeals
Hi Jan
ME/CFS is definitely recognised and accepted as real and debilitating by the DWP for incapacity benefits purposes. I have been awarded higher rates of DLA and support group ESA purely based on my level of incapacity due to severe ME/CFS.
Good luck with your appeal,
Rainbowlight
ME/CFS is definitely recognised and accepted as real and debilitating by the DWP for incapacity benefits purposes. I have been awarded higher rates of DLA and support group ESA purely based on my level of incapacity due to severe ME/CFS.
Good luck with your appeal,
Rainbowlight
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- jan
- Topic Author
14 years 1 week ago #34415 by jan
Replied by jan on topic Re:ESA and DLA claims and appeals
Hi Dave and Rainbowlight,
Thank you both for your comments.
Did have varous occupational health reports and from our local hospital based ME/CFS unit last year when i first signed up.
Since then all I have is my GP as I haven't been referred to the local hopsital etc. It seems to me that they look for these referrals to substantiate your claim - how does one go about reinforcing a condition without these and not being on medication for them because your body doesn't like them? From what I can see it makes it harder without these bearing in mind folks stance on these two condition.
Thank you both for your comments.
Did have varous occupational health reports and from our local hospital based ME/CFS unit last year when i first signed up.
Since then all I have is my GP as I haven't been referred to the local hopsital etc. It seems to me that they look for these referrals to substantiate your claim - how does one go about reinforcing a condition without these and not being on medication for them because your body doesn't like them? From what I can see it makes it harder without these bearing in mind folks stance on these two condition.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Gordon
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 51290
14 years 1 week ago #34428 by Gordon
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by Gordon on topic Re:ESA and DLA claims and appeals
jan
I would not worry about the medication, there is no official medicinal treatment for ME/CFS, most people are given something for the associated illnesses such as depression or to aid with some of the symptons such as disturbed sleep.
With regard to arguing your case, you should look at the effects of your ME/CFS over more than one day, remember it is how you are for the majority of the time that counts.
Also you should consider the issue of "reasonable repeatability". If you are not able to repeat a test with in a reasonable period then you are considered to incapable of carrying out the test for that day.
Hope this helps
Stephen
I would not worry about the medication, there is no official medicinal treatment for ME/CFS, most people are given something for the associated illnesses such as depression or to aid with some of the symptons such as disturbed sleep.
With regard to arguing your case, you should look at the effects of your ME/CFS over more than one day, remember it is how you are for the majority of the time that counts.
Also you should consider the issue of "reasonable repeatability". If you are not able to repeat a test with in a reasonable period then you are considered to incapable of carrying out the test for that day.
Hope this helps
Stephen
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- DRAGON2009
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 654
14 years 1 week ago #34429 by DRAGON2009
Replied by DRAGON2009 on topic Re:ESA and DLA claims and appeals
You could keep a diary for a while to record how your days are and their variation.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: Gordon, Gary, BIS, Catherine, Wendy, Kelly, greekqueen, peter, Katherine, Super User, Chris, David