- Posts: 15
 
- Forum
 - Members forums
 - ESA, PIP, UC and DLA Queries and Results
 - ESA Appeal Review without attending tribunal
 
 			× 			Members		
 	 	ESA Appeal Review without attending tribunal
- catvinnat
 - Topic Author
 - Offline
 
 		Less 		More 		 			 	
 		 			 	 						15 years 9 hours ago				#33831 		by catvinnat 	  	 		 			 	    			 			 		 													
 	 				ESA Appeal Review without attending tribunal was created by catvinnat			
  			 				My husband suffers from PTSD and has been absent from work since April 2009. He had his medical in December 09 ans scored a derisory 6 points.  Sadly he is still too ill to work .
With the help of this website we submitted an appeal with supporting medical evidence including 5 reports from his consulktant. The appeal was lodged with the tribunals service in January and we were led to expect a hearing in July but had no date set.
Today hubby has received a letter which I quote
'about your support allowance appeal
I have been advised that the appeals officer has reviewed the decision on your case and that the new decision is a more favourable one.
This means that your appeal has now lapsed and I will take no further action.
If you think the new decision is still wrong you must lodge a fresh appeal.'
 
Not really understanding what this means I rang the tribunals service and the lovely lady I spoke too says they are part of a pilot scheme to reduce the burdon on the tribunals service. A team of 5 are reviewing disputed cases where points have been awarded at ESA medicals to try and free up the 15000 backlog at the office where they normally handle some 5000 appeals per year.
She believes it means that hubby has effectively won his appeal though we have to wait for confirmation from DWP who may not have been informed yet.
I'll update this thread as soon as I have more concrete news as it may have ramiffications for many other members
  					With the help of this website we submitted an appeal with supporting medical evidence including 5 reports from his consulktant. The appeal was lodged with the tribunals service in January and we were led to expect a hearing in July but had no date set.
Today hubby has received a letter which I quote
'about your support allowance appeal
I have been advised that the appeals officer has reviewed the decision on your case and that the new decision is a more favourable one.
This means that your appeal has now lapsed and I will take no further action.
If you think the new decision is still wrong you must lodge a fresh appeal.'
Not really understanding what this means I rang the tribunals service and the lovely lady I spoke too says they are part of a pilot scheme to reduce the burdon on the tribunals service. A team of 5 are reviewing disputed cases where points have been awarded at ESA medicals to try and free up the 15000 backlog at the office where they normally handle some 5000 appeals per year.
She believes it means that hubby has effectively won his appeal though we have to wait for confirmation from DWP who may not have been informed yet.
I'll update this thread as soon as I have more concrete news as it may have ramiffications for many other members
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- susan
 - Offline
 
 		Less 		More 		 			 	
 		- Posts: 58
 
 			 	 						15 years 7 hours ago				#33843 		by susan  	  	 		 			 	    			 			 		 													
 	 				Replied by susan  on topic Re: ESA Appeal Review without attending tribunal			
  			 				I hope she is correct. well done. I just recieved a letter today so say I score 0 points so I am just starting the appeal process. Im not happy as the assessor has obviously wrote what she wanted and not what i told her or my evidence provided
Hope you get a letter of comfimation soon
susan
  					Hope you get a letter of comfimation soon
susan
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Steve Donnison
 - Offline
 
 		Less 		More 		 			 	
 		- Posts: 929
 
 			 	 						14 years 11 months ago				#35464 		by Steve Donnison 	  	 		 			 					
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems 					 	    			 			 		 													
 	 				Replied by Steve Donnison on topic Re: ESA Appeal Review without attending tribunal			
  			 				Hi catvinnat,
 
I've just seen your post today, my apologies for not replying sooner.
 
If your husband's appeal has lapsed because of a more favourable decision that can indeed only mean that he has been awarded ESA, otherwise the appeal would be continuing.
 
You will need to wait until you get a decision letter before you know which group he has been put in.
 
If it is the work-related activity group and your husband believes he qualifies for the support group he can still put in a fresh appeal, although there are risks attached to doing this. See our guide to ESA appeals for more on this.
 
Good luck,
 
Steve
  							I've just seen your post today, my apologies for not replying sooner.
If your husband's appeal has lapsed because of a more favourable decision that can indeed only mean that he has been awarded ESA, otherwise the appeal would be continuing.
You will need to wait until you get a decision letter before you know which group he has been put in.
If it is the work-related activity group and your husband believes he qualifies for the support group he can still put in a fresh appeal, although there are risks attached to doing this. See our guide to ESA appeals for more on this.
Good luck,
Steve
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- catvinnat
 - Topic Author
 - Offline
 
 		Less 		More 		 			 	
 		- Posts: 15
 
 			 	 						14 years 11 months ago				#35472 		by catvinnat 	  	 		 			 	    			 			 		 													
 	 				Replied by catvinnat on topic Re: ESA Appeal Review without attending tribunal			
  			 				Thanks Steve
we are still waiting for DWP to inform hubby of which group. I suspect it will be the WR one but whatever, at least its some progress even if it only lasts for a year before he loses his contributions based esa.
Sadly he is now under inordinate pressure from his employer so we have a competency hearing to deal with rather than a tribunal.
I am just awaiting a callback with some legal advise as we may have a strong employment tribunal case for constructive dismissal following their latest dispicable tactic.
We shall see.....
thanks for your support
  					we are still waiting for DWP to inform hubby of which group. I suspect it will be the WR one but whatever, at least its some progress even if it only lasts for a year before he loses his contributions based esa.
Sadly he is now under inordinate pressure from his employer so we have a competency hearing to deal with rather than a tribunal.
I am just awaiting a callback with some legal advise as we may have a strong employment tribunal case for constructive dismissal following their latest dispicable tactic.
We shall see.....
thanks for your support
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- catvinnat
 - Topic Author
 - Offline
 
 		Less 		More 		 			 	
 		- Posts: 15
 
 			 	 						14 years 11 months ago				#37702 		by catvinnat 	  	 		 			 	    			 			 		 													
 	 				Replied by catvinnat on topic Re:ESA Appeal Review without attending tribunal			
  			 				after 3 weeks of chasing the DWP being passed from pillar to post with no further news I rang the tribunals service again.  The lovely lady I first spoke to has dug out hubby's file and the result (we believe)is that he's been put in the support group - quite a change from the original 6 points he was given by ATOS.
No celebrations yet as we won't believe it til we get it in writing but if its true it will be a tremendous relief.
 
To anyone who is wondering whether its worth all the hassle just do it. The onfo on this website is the best, we wouldn't have had the heart or the courage to plough on otherwise.
 
Next stop DLA!
			
  					No celebrations yet as we won't believe it til we get it in writing but if its true it will be a tremendous relief.
To anyone who is wondering whether its worth all the hassle just do it. The onfo on this website is the best, we wouldn't have had the heart or the courage to plough on otherwise.
Next stop DLA!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- pattie57
 
 			 	 						14 years 11 months ago				#37732 		by pattie57 	  	 		 			 				
 HI ,CONGRATULATIONS SURE YOU LL GET A LETTER SOON
YOUR COMMENTS ABOUT THE BACKLOG ETC WERE INTERESTING
ALL THE BEST WITH YOUR DLA YOUR HUSBAND DESERVES IT AFTER
GOING THROUGH ALL THIS. IT HAS OBVIOUSLY BEEN A LONG STRESSFUL
BATTLE YOU COULD DO WITHOUT BUT AS YOU SAID WITHOUT THIS WEB SITE MOST OF US WOULD GIVE UP!
I HAVE JUST BEEN TOLD ON THE PHONE MY ESA CLAIM HAS BEEN DISALLOWED EVEN THOUGH I SCORED ENOUGH POINTS TO BE A"BORDERLINE DECISION"
LOOKS LIKE I AM JOINING THE CROWD WITH AN APPEAL THE NEXT STAGE  					 	    			 			 		 													
 	 				Replied by pattie57 on topic Re:ESA Appeal Review without attending tribunal			
  			YOUR COMMENTS ABOUT THE BACKLOG ETC WERE INTERESTING
ALL THE BEST WITH YOUR DLA YOUR HUSBAND DESERVES IT AFTER
GOING THROUGH ALL THIS. IT HAS OBVIOUSLY BEEN A LONG STRESSFUL
BATTLE YOU COULD DO WITHOUT BUT AS YOU SAID WITHOUT THIS WEB SITE MOST OF US WOULD GIVE UP!
I HAVE JUST BEEN TOLD ON THE PHONE MY ESA CLAIM HAS BEEN DISALLOWED EVEN THOUGH I SCORED ENOUGH POINTS TO BE A"BORDERLINE DECISION"
LOOKS LIKE I AM JOINING THE CROWD WITH AN APPEAL THE NEXT STAGE
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
 		Moderators: Gordon, latetrain, BIS, Catherine12345, Chris, David, Keely