- Posts: 27
× Members
URGENT HELP PLEASE
- Michala
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
2 years 2 months ago #273457 by Michala
URGENT HELP PLEASE was created by Michala
Hi once again,
I am trying to make my appeal to the DWP to award me standard rate for both components for PIP, when previously after an appeal I was awarded enhanced rate for both components.
I have not completed an appeal application online before, and I only have 2 weeks to be within 13 months deadline following MR. I do have extenuating circumstances regarding this. However, the deadline is looming.
My question is:
"What you disagree with"
Do I just put that I disagree with being awarded what I was awarded for both elements of PIP, and then in the following box "Why you disagree" , can I just copy and paste my full submission, with potted history, etc.?
Any help would be hugely appreciated.
Thank you in advance,
Michala
I am trying to make my appeal to the DWP to award me standard rate for both components for PIP, when previously after an appeal I was awarded enhanced rate for both components.
I have not completed an appeal application online before, and I only have 2 weeks to be within 13 months deadline following MR. I do have extenuating circumstances regarding this. However, the deadline is looming.
My question is:
"What you disagree with"
Do I just put that I disagree with being awarded what I was awarded for both elements of PIP, and then in the following box "Why you disagree" , can I just copy and paste my full submission, with potted history, etc.?
Any help would be hugely appreciated.
Thank you in advance,
Michala
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- LL26
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 1420
2 years 2 months ago #273469 by LL26
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by LL26 on topic URGENT HELP PLEASE
Hi Michala,
What you disagree with can be a one line statement. 'I wasn't awarded PIP,' or several pages of legal argument, explaining everything. You can cut nd paste if required You can also indicate the correct points value if you like.
I suggest that given this is a very late appeal you give as much detail as possible.
Do explain the lateness in full, you are very late so will need a very good reason. Send in relevant documents if these will help show your reason.
Dwp may not agree you can appeal, if so they will send the matter to the tribunal for a preliminary ruling as to whether you can actually appeal.
You may wish to include reference to Article 6 ECHR- right to access justice- if you re not allowed to appeal. Also Article 1 of Protocol 1 is the right to have peaceful enjoyment of your own possessions, which is also called the right to property. The right to property also includes the right to receive social security benefit . If you lose the right to appeal you are likely to lose the right to receive the correct benefit to which you feel you are entitled. (Explain eg you were declined because there was such poor assessment report etc, which was completely wrong and DWP should not have relied on it etc.)
Anyway, send in your appeal NOW as you risk missing the deadline!
I hope this helps.
LL26
What you disagree with can be a one line statement. 'I wasn't awarded PIP,' or several pages of legal argument, explaining everything. You can cut nd paste if required You can also indicate the correct points value if you like.
I suggest that given this is a very late appeal you give as much detail as possible.
Do explain the lateness in full, you are very late so will need a very good reason. Send in relevant documents if these will help show your reason.
Dwp may not agree you can appeal, if so they will send the matter to the tribunal for a preliminary ruling as to whether you can actually appeal.
You may wish to include reference to Article 6 ECHR- right to access justice- if you re not allowed to appeal. Also Article 1 of Protocol 1 is the right to have peaceful enjoyment of your own possessions, which is also called the right to property. The right to property also includes the right to receive social security benefit . If you lose the right to appeal you are likely to lose the right to receive the correct benefit to which you feel you are entitled. (Explain eg you were declined because there was such poor assessment report etc, which was completely wrong and DWP should not have relied on it etc.)
Anyway, send in your appeal NOW as you risk missing the deadline!
I hope this helps.
LL26
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
The following user(s) said Thank You: denby
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Michala
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 27
2 years 2 months ago #273577 by Michala
Replied by Michala on topic URGENT HELP PLEASE
Dear all,
Thank you LL26 for your reply to my previous post, I truly appreciate all of your help.
I am doing my best to get this appeal submitted as soon as possible but I am experiencing a significant deterioration in my physical health due to suffering from a cerebral spinal fluid leak, which is causing a low pressure headache, as well as additional symptoms that leave me feeling like I have dementia. I need to keep lying flat to help alleviate my severe headache. Unfortunately, I have no one to assist me with this, and have no time to find someone. So I am doing my best to battle through.
So, I have gone through the bundle I have received from the DWP following my freedom of information request, that equates to over 500 sheets. In this information I have found a comment in the DWP communications that states my medical assessment for my ESA is too old (which was a face-to-face) and so it says that they have just used the HP telephone assessment to make their decision. They have made no mention to the additional supporting evidence I supplied to support my claim. So, can I assume that they have made their decision solely on the HP's assessment?
When I requested a mandatory reconsideration I sent in a 20 page document pulling their original decision apart. Would this be sent to the tribunal or do I use this as evidence to support my appeal. The reconsideration decision, has what I can only state as shocking reasons for their "reasoning" if you can call it that!?!? So am I best doing the same again, like I did for the the original decision, or do I just explain what points I was awarded and why I disagree.
I have compared my original points awarded to the ones then awarded after my first appeal, and now the ones awarded this time. The appeal increased my points for preparing food, managing treatments, and planning and following a route. Although, I consider myself to have additional difficulties, am I best just focusing my efforts on trying to regain the points that I have lost, so that I can hopefully win my appeal?
Sorry for all of the questions but I am struggling due to my head to decide on the best way to proceed. Sitting in front of a computer screen, and trying to fill out a form online is incredibly difficult for me.
Thanks once again,
Michala
Thank you LL26 for your reply to my previous post, I truly appreciate all of your help.
I am doing my best to get this appeal submitted as soon as possible but I am experiencing a significant deterioration in my physical health due to suffering from a cerebral spinal fluid leak, which is causing a low pressure headache, as well as additional symptoms that leave me feeling like I have dementia. I need to keep lying flat to help alleviate my severe headache. Unfortunately, I have no one to assist me with this, and have no time to find someone. So I am doing my best to battle through.
So, I have gone through the bundle I have received from the DWP following my freedom of information request, that equates to over 500 sheets. In this information I have found a comment in the DWP communications that states my medical assessment for my ESA is too old (which was a face-to-face) and so it says that they have just used the HP telephone assessment to make their decision. They have made no mention to the additional supporting evidence I supplied to support my claim. So, can I assume that they have made their decision solely on the HP's assessment?
When I requested a mandatory reconsideration I sent in a 20 page document pulling their original decision apart. Would this be sent to the tribunal or do I use this as evidence to support my appeal. The reconsideration decision, has what I can only state as shocking reasons for their "reasoning" if you can call it that!?!? So am I best doing the same again, like I did for the the original decision, or do I just explain what points I was awarded and why I disagree.
I have compared my original points awarded to the ones then awarded after my first appeal, and now the ones awarded this time. The appeal increased my points for preparing food, managing treatments, and planning and following a route. Although, I consider myself to have additional difficulties, am I best just focusing my efforts on trying to regain the points that I have lost, so that I can hopefully win my appeal?
Sorry for all of the questions but I am struggling due to my head to decide on the best way to proceed. Sitting in front of a computer screen, and trying to fill out a form online is incredibly difficult for me.
Thanks once again,
Michala
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Gary
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 8169
2 years 2 months ago #273603 by Gary
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by Gary on topic URGENT HELP PLEASE
Hi Michala
When ever I do a submission I set out what the assessor has scored on the PA4 for each descriptor and the what I believe they should be scored and why, the why part is the important part where you explain why you believe you should be awarded the points.
If there are any errors under History, current medication, social and occupational history then explain what the errors are, if you have any supporting documents, then tie the error with the documents.
Quite often I come across assessments which state the claimant had no specialist involvement. If the claimant is seeing a psychiatrist but waiting for an appointment then I will refer to the letter informing waiting to see a specialist.
Gary
When ever I do a submission I set out what the assessor has scored on the PA4 for each descriptor and the what I believe they should be scored and why, the why part is the important part where you explain why you believe you should be awarded the points.
If there are any errors under History, current medication, social and occupational history then explain what the errors are, if you have any supporting documents, then tie the error with the documents.
Quite often I come across assessments which state the claimant had no specialist involvement. If the claimant is seeing a psychiatrist but waiting for an appointment then I will refer to the letter informing waiting to see a specialist.
Gary
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
The following user(s) said Thank You: Michala
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Michala
- Topic Author
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 27
2 years 1 week ago #275005 by Michala
Replied by Michala on topic URGENT HELP PLEASE
Hi,
Well I have some news...
I have heard nothing from either the DWP or the Tribunal Service since I submitted my appeal at 00.15 on 27th September 2022. This was the the final day of the 13 month rule, so I was certainly cutting it close to the wire.
I contacted them about a week later using the live chat because I had received no notification that my appeal had been received. I was given a link to track the progress but this failed to work. I've not been able to chase it up until last week when I sent an email, and received an automated response. Well today I received both a text and an email saying that the "DWP have changed their decision about my entitlement to PIP in my favour. We've therefore closed this appeal."
I am in total shock. I have since rang the DWP and it has been confirmed that my entitlement has been changed to enhanced rate for both daily living and mobility from standard rate until May 2024, and is being back dated to May 2021.
I have certainly learnt so much about how this system works and will definitely learn from the mistakes I made. I will be well prepare for when my entitlement is being reviewed again.
All I can say is a massive thank you to you all, as this is life changing for me. I have been without a car for over a year (as a had to return my Motability car) with a now 3 year old living in a rural setting, and due to my complex health conditions I am unable to use public transport. So I totally lost my independence.
So thank you once again, and I hope that my success will encourage others to pursue what they are truly entitled to.
Best wishes,
Michala
Well I have some news...
I have heard nothing from either the DWP or the Tribunal Service since I submitted my appeal at 00.15 on 27th September 2022. This was the the final day of the 13 month rule, so I was certainly cutting it close to the wire.
I contacted them about a week later using the live chat because I had received no notification that my appeal had been received. I was given a link to track the progress but this failed to work. I've not been able to chase it up until last week when I sent an email, and received an automated response. Well today I received both a text and an email saying that the "DWP have changed their decision about my entitlement to PIP in my favour. We've therefore closed this appeal."
I am in total shock. I have since rang the DWP and it has been confirmed that my entitlement has been changed to enhanced rate for both daily living and mobility from standard rate until May 2024, and is being back dated to May 2021.
I have certainly learnt so much about how this system works and will definitely learn from the mistakes I made. I will be well prepare for when my entitlement is being reviewed again.
All I can say is a massive thank you to you all, as this is life changing for me. I have been without a car for over a year (as a had to return my Motability car) with a now 3 year old living in a rural setting, and due to my complex health conditions I am unable to use public transport. So I totally lost my independence.
So thank you once again, and I hope that my success will encourage others to pursue what they are truly entitled to.
Best wishes,
Michala
The following user(s) said Thank You: denby, ivyfox, Gary, AliBee, LL26
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- BIS
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 8361
2 years 1 week ago #275015 by BIS
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by BIS on topic URGENT HELP PLEASE
Hi Michala
What wonderful news. Many congratulations. So glad you didn't actually have to go through with the appeal and that you now have your money backdated.
And good for you for acknowledging that you will be able to defend yourself better at the next review from what you have learned.
I'm glad you will be able to get back your independence.
BIS
Tags: @RESULT @PIP
What wonderful news. Many congratulations. So glad you didn't actually have to go through with the appeal and that you now have your money backdated.
And good for you for acknowledging that you will be able to defend yourself better at the next review from what you have learned.
I'm glad you will be able to get back your independence.
BIS
Tags: @RESULT @PIP
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
The following user(s) said Thank You: Michala
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: Gordon, Gary, BIS, Catherine, Wendy, Kelly, greekqueen, peter, Katherine, Super User, Chris, David